When something goes wrong on board, the first hours decide how the claim is handled later. This lesson is an original summary of the master's first actions for the eight most common P&I situations, based on a P&I club's Master's Handbook (Japan P&I Club). Your own P&I club's circulars, your company's SMS, the flag State and local law always take precedence. Club cover depends on your club's rules and the entry terms.
The same rule in every case
- People first: saving life, then protecting the ship and the environment.
- Notify early: the owners or managers, then the agent and the club's local P&I correspondent.
- Record facts, not opinions: times, positions, weather, names of witnesses, photos, logbook entries.
- Keep the evidence: printouts, VDR/ECDIS data, samples, damaged parts.
- Be careful with statements: check who the investigator is, tell the truth, read everything before signing, and never admit liability.
1. Crew claims: injury, illness, death, missing, jump ship
According to the handbook, crew claims make up more than 30% of what the club pays out. Typical causes are slips and falls, being struck by cargo, a wire or a rope, entering enclosed spaces that have not been properly gas-freed, and illnesses linked to lifestyle.
- Injury or illness at sea: give first aid, get medical advice from a rescue or medical centre (TMAS), notify the owners, and consider changing course to a port or asking for a helicopter. Record the time, place and cause, and take witness statements.
- Missing crew member: find out when and where they were last seen, check their cabin, search the ship (including hidden spaces), search the sea area, and notify the owners, agent, authorities and correspondent.
- Jump ship: check their belongings, interview shipmates, and notify everyone concerned. Immigration may impose a fine or require a guarantee.
- The Master's report is the key evidence for deciding whether a case was work-related. Keep it factual and objective, and attach photos and witness statements.
2. Stowaways and refugees
- Prevention is the best protection: in risk ports, run gangway control, keep spaces locked and search the ship before sailing.
- If a stowaway is found, treat them humanely, search them, keep them secure and fed, and record their identity and how they boarded. Notify the owners and the club straight away, because disembarking and repatriating stowaways depends on agreement from the authorities.
- Refugees or migrants rescued at sea are a duty to save life under SOLAS and SAR. Coordinate with the rescue coordination centre (RCC) and notify the owners and the club.
3. Personal injury to third parties
Typical examples are a stevedore slipping on deck, an official falling from the gangway, a linesman hit by a heaving-line weight, and a parted mooring line. Keep access arrangements in good condition, keep people out of snap-back zones, and record and photograph the scene. Sign any claim only as "receipt acknowledged", without accepting liability.
4. Cargo claims
Common causes are leaking hatch covers, condensation (sweat), contamination, heat damage from fuel heating, reefer failures, poor lashing and differences in quantity. To prevent them: use due diligence to make the ship seaworthy, inspect holds and tanks before loading, close up for rain, keep tally or soundings, record cargo, weather and route in the log, and check B/L remarks. See Cargo claims.
Key documents: sea protest and deck log (heavy weather); letter of protest, draft survey and ullage report (shortage); tank inspection certificate and cleaning record (contamination); chief engineer's fuel-heating report (heat damage); temperature and ventilation records (reefer cargo).
5. Salvage, LOF and SCOPIC
- In an emergency, a Lloyd's Open Form (LOF) can be agreed by radio. Get the owners' instructions wherever possible, and send them a copy of the agreement once it is signed.
- Who pays: salvage reward comes from the hull and cargo underwriters. SCOPIC (special compensation, usually linked to environmental risk) comes from the P&I club. SCOPIC applies only if it is written into the agreement (LOF Box 7), and the salvors must invoke it. Security is then required within 2 working days.
- A Special Casualty Representative (SCR) may attend for the property underwriters. Cooperate with them. Keep your statements factual, and share the cause of the casualty only with the owners' side.
6. Damage to fixed and floating property (FFO)
Examples include berths, cranes, buoys and other vessels. Record who was on the bridge, whether a pilot or tugs were in use, course, speed, engine and rudder orders, and draft. Then photograph and sketch the damage and note any old damage that was already there. Answer the terminal's damage report with a "receipt only" signature.
7. Collision
- Life first, then assess your own damage and take action to prevent further loss. Stand by the other vessel as required by law.
- Do not admit liability at the scene. Exchange a Notice of Claim (sign the other side's notice "for receipt only").
- Keep records: VDR, ECDIS, radar, engine logger, course recorder and logs.
- Statements: cooperate with your owners' lawyers, surveyors and correspondent, and with the marine authority. Turn down interviews by the other side's lawyers or surveyors unless your owners' representatives are present.
- Typical causes are poor lookout, breaches of the COLREG steering and sailing rules, too much speed and fatigue. See COLREGs.
8. Oil pollution
- Act first on the ship: stop the leak, depressurise tanks and lines, transfer oil to other tanks, control stability and trim, keep gas out of the engine room and accommodation, and remove sources of ignition.
- Report immediately under the SOPEP/SMPEP to the coastal State, owners and club. Report the quantity accurately, and use dispersants only with the authority's approval.
- Liability rules differ: tankers fall under CLC/Fund, bunker spills under the Bunkers Convention, and some countries have their own laws, such as OPA 90 in the USA.
Self-test
- What five things apply to every P&I incident?
Answer 1
Life first, notify early (owners, agent, P&I correspondent), record facts, keep evidence, and give careful statements with no admission of liability.
- How should the Master sign a claim or damage notice presented by a third party?
Answer 2
"For receipt only" or "receipt acknowledged", without accepting liability.
- Who normally pays salvage reward, and who pays SCOPIC?
Answer 3
Salvage reward comes from the hull and machinery (H&M) and cargo underwriters. SCOPIC comes from the P&I club.
- After a collision, may the Master give an interview to the other vessel's lawyers?
Answer 4
No, unless the owners' own representatives are present and agree. Cooperate fully with your own side and with the marine authority.
- Why is the Master's report so important in a crew injury case?
Answer 5
It is the key evidence for deciding whether the injury or illness was work-related, so it must be factual and supported by witness statements and photos.
- Which document set supports a heavy-weather cargo damage defence?
Answer 6
The sea protest, the deck logbook, and the Master's report on the action taken to avoid rough seas.
References
- Japan P&I Club, Master's Handbook (summarised, not reproduced).
- Lloyd's Open Form (LOF) and SCOPIC Clause.
- IMO conventions: CLC 1992, Fund 1992, Bunkers 2001, SOLAS Chapter V (SAR).
- See also Marine insurance and General Average.
Collision case study
The Solong & Stena Immaculate collision case study provides an official-source factual sequence for discussing the transition from collision to cargo fire, missing-person search, abandonment, pollution response and claims preservation. Its interim safety-investigation purpose is separate from legal liability.